Writer beta - Windows Live
Posted on October 5th, 2008 in braindump
Okay, I kinda really hate to do this, but I have admit I’m sold on Windows Live Writer.
The Window’s Live Suite (of course it’s a suite, this is Microsoft, have they ever made anything standalone?) is mostly stuff that’s useless for me (messenger, hotmail, other stuff I haven’t touched since 1999). I’m also not much of a desktop webapp user (with the exception of Twirl, which I use when the update du jour plays nicely with the rest of my system).
But, on a lark, I took a look at Live Writer. And I’m surprisingly sold on several intelligent decisions from installation to implementation.
First off, yeah, it’s a suite, but MS has finally figured out that it shouldn’t be a goddamned chore to just install one bit. I don’t need or want integration with a mail client, messenger, photo gallery (sure would like Flicker integration, but I understand), or “family” blocking functionality. Instead of forcing a full install and making you remove bits later, or slipping in a custom option halfway through the install, the Live Suite installer has tickboxes at the very beginning of the process. It’s a small change, but one that saves about 10 microseconds of time and, more importantly, shows some real understanding on the part of Microsoft that modular installs should, in fact, be modular.
Install depends on the .NET framework, which you’ve probably already got if you’re running windows, or will install itself if not. If your running Mac or Linux, I’ve got no idea what the install looks like, or even if there’s an option for you – but there are about 8 billion Mac-only options out there, and you Linux users made the conscious decision to opt out of corporate software when you picked your system. Go see what Opera’s got for you or something.
For BlogThis functionality, IE is of course automatic – there’s a whole toolbar thingie if you want all the other suite stuff jacked in, too. But, on the dealmaker end (for me) there’s a working (and working well!!) Firefox plugin, too. I’m running it on FF3.0.3, and the highlight or full page functionality work equally well.
So onto the actual Live Writer interface thinga.
It does precisely what it’s supposed to. I don’t imagine it’s anything but perfect for Windows Live blogs, but I’m obviously running Wordpress. There are many other desktop blogging apps that jack into WP installs out there, of course, with varying degrees of success. If you’re already using one of those, and it’s working for you, there’s probably little reason to change. But setup for Live Writer on WP requires no fussing with settings or extra plugins – the first time you start the app, you simply choose “another weblog service” from the setup window, enter the url of the top of your blog, your username and password for admin, and hit enter.
You’ll immediately be taken to a wysiwyg compose window. And, usually, I really hate those. I’d rather get at the html, especially in Wordpress, because WP wysiwyg has classically been a buggy POS if you’re embedding anything from tables to YouTube. Live Writer’s wysiwyg, on the other hand, goes one step++ and grabs the CSS off your blog install so what you see really is exactly what you get – font size, color, spacing, padding, headers – everything displays in real time precisely as it’s going to show up when you hit post. No need to preview to make sure the image you’ve just added will be wider than your blog column width, WLW not only autoscales to fit whatever your CSS says the column width is, you can see it working right from the compose window. Ditto with blockquotes or, if you switch to and back from html view, any div or style tags. I’ve seen this functionality in other desktop blog apps, but I’m pleasantly surprised at how nicely it’s implemented, here.
All the extra nonsense you’ve got access to from a Wordpress compose panel is available bottom of screen, too. Tags, cats, author, slug, password, optional excerpt, trackbacks, custom date, save as draft turn on/off comments and pings – it’s all there and works flawlessly.
Insert Table also works. If you’ve ever spent twenty minutes trying to figure out what the fuck WP did to the table you know should be working, let me repeat that – Insert Table actually works.
(As do, obviously, hotkeys ctrl+I, B, C, P, Z, etc, as in Word.)
So, there you go. Not the greatest app of all time, not amazingly revolutionary, but if you’re looking for a “Holy Crap it just works” desktop app for making blog posts that you can use from your browser and has a relatively small footprint (if you’re not installing all the other bits, the largest part of the install is the .NET framework, and if you’ve just purchased a new computer, it’s all likely already installed), I’ve got no cautionary tales for Live Writer.














